How to Reheat Cold Pizza | Reheat Pizza Leftover Tips

How to Reheat Cold Pizza

Are you always left with leftover slices of pizza after a cozy night of pizza and Netflix? If you're like most of us, you know the struggle is real when it comes to discovering the best way to reheat pizza. We've all been there, waking up to a box full of day-old pizza, craving for that crispy, fresh-out-of-the-oven goodness. It's one of those universal dilemmas where you find yourself staring at that cold, firm slice of pizza, questioning if there is any way to revive its day one glory.

Pizza is a dish that deserves a second chance, and a soggy, lukewarm slice just doesn't cut it. You don't want to have a pizza that tastes like a shadow of its former glorious self, right?

That's where we come in, with proven tips and techniques to bring back the life of that cold pizza, making it as satisfying as the moment it was first delivered. After all, every slice of pizza deserves its moment of crunch and flavor.

So stick around, as we unfold the secrets of reheating pizza to perfection. Who knows, you might find that the best slice you ever had is actually one that's been reheated the right way.

Oven Method

When it comes to reheating pizza, the oven method stands tall as a classic and reliable choice.

  1. The first thing to do is to preheat the oven. Dial it up to 375°F (190°C) and let it warm up while you prepare the pizza.
  2. Take out the leftover slice or slices from the fridge. If they're in a box, transfer them to a baking sheet. While you might be tempted to just throw them onto the rack, using a baking sheet helps ensure even heating and avert any topping-related mishaps. It's all about balance here: you want to melt the cheese without burning the pizza's crust.
  3. Pop the pizza in the oven once it's preheated. This is where the magic happens, as the dry heat of the oven helps maintain that crispy crust we all crave while simultaneously melting the cheese to gooey perfection.
  4. Keep a close eye on the pizza while it cooks, as every oven is slightly different. 
  5. Take out your pizza once the cheese is bubbly and the crust has regained its snap. A limp crust is no fun, so take care not to undercook.

Generally, it should take about 6-8 minutes to reheat pizza in the oven to get it just right.

Air Fryer Method

Another method you can do is using an air fryer to reheat a slice or two of your favorite pizza. This relatively new kitchen gadget has been a game-changer for pizza lovers, offering a quick and easy way to achieve a perfectly crispy crust in no time at all.

  1. Start by preheating your air fryer to 350°F (175°C) for a couple of minutes. While waiting, prepare your cold pizza slices.
  2. Once the air fryer is ready, place the pizza directly into the basket. You don't need to worry about the toppings falling off as the rapid air circulation inside the air fryer evenly cooks and crisps the pizza from all sides.
  3. The pizza usually takes around 3-4 minutes to reheat, but it's worth keeping an eye on it to avoid overcooking. The air fryer is very efficient at crisping up the crust while ensuring the topping is well heated and the cheese is meltingly good.
  4. Once done, carefully remove the pizza from the air fryer. You'll find that the crust is as crisp as if it was freshly baked, and the toppings are warm and bubbling.

This method makes the pizza taste almost as good as when it was first delivered. And the best part is, it's super quick and simple, making it perfect for those late-night pizza cravings or a quick lunch.

Non-Stick Pan Method

Non-Stick Pan Method

If you don't have access to an oven or an air fryer, don't fret. There's still a fantastic way to reheat pizza the right way, and that's using a non-stick pan or a cast-iron skillet. Yes, you heard it right! You can reheat pizza in a pan, and it's surprisingly effective.

  1. Start by heating your non-stick pan or cast-iron pan over medium heat. Allow the pan to get hot, but not smoking. While your pan is heating, prepare your pizza slices. You don't need any oil for this method as the fats in the pizza will do all the work for you.
  2. Place your cold pizza slice in the hot pan. Cook for a couple of minutes until the underside of the crust begins to get crispy. Here's the clever part: add a few drops of water to the pan (away from the pizza) and quickly cover the pan with a lid. This creates a bit of steam, helping to melt the cheese and warm the toppings without making them soggy.
  3. After another minute or two, your slice should be ready. The bottom will be nice and crispy, and the cheese on top nice and melty.

Using a pan with a lid to reheat pizza is a great method that uses tools you likely already have in your kitchen. With this method, a leftover slice is transformed into a deliciously warmed, revived pizza that's just as satisfying as it was on day one.

Stovetop Method

In some situations, the easiest way to reheat leftover pizza is right on your stovetop.

  1. To do this, start by placing your pizza slice directly onto a cold non-stick pan. This method is very similar to the one above, but with a slight twist.
  2. Cover the top of the pizza slice with a piece of aluminum foil to create a makeshift lid. This will help retain heat and warm up the toppings and cheese, while the direct heat crisps up the pizza crust.
  3. Place the pan on the burner and turn the heat to medium-low. Allow the pizza to warm slowly; this will typically take about five minutes, but keep a close eye to avoid burning.

With this method, your pizza on the stovetop will reheat evenly, ensuring a crispy crust and a perfectly warmed, cheesy topping.

Microwave Method

Now, if you're really in a rush, the fastest way to reheat pizza is undoubtedly the microwave. This method might not give you a crispy crust, but it is the quickest.

  1. To reheat pizza in the microwave, place a slice on a microwave-safe plate.
  2. Set the microwave to 50% power; this lower power setting helps the heat to distribute more evenly, preventing the edges from getting hard while the middle is still cold.
  3. The time to reheat will vary depending on your microwave and the size of the slice, but generally, it should take between 30 seconds to a minute.
  4. Once the cheese starts to melt, it's ready to eat. Let the pizza stand for a moment before eating as the toppings may be extremely hot.

While not the best for reheating in terms of texture, the microwave method does get points for being the quickest, and sometimes, speed is the key!

Useful Tips When Reheating Pizza

Useful Tips When Reheating Pizza

Reheating pizza can be a bit of an art. It's all about bringing back to life that perfect balance between a crisp crust and meltingly saucy topping. So, how do you reheat pizza so it tastes just as good, if not better, than when it was fresh? Here are some useful tips to help you.

  1. Know your slice: The method you choose might depend on what toppings you have. For a slice loaded with veggies or pepperoni, methods like the oven or air fryer are better as they'll fully heat the toppings. For a plain cheese slice, the stovetop or microwave might suffice.

  2. Preheat properly: If you're using an oven, air fryer, or a pan, give it time to heat up properly before adding the pizza. This ensures that the pizza heats quickly, keeping the crust crisp and the toppings fresh.

  3. Don’t Rush: While the microwave is the quickest option, if you want to reheat pizza to its former glory, it’s worth using a method that takes a bit more time. More time in a heated environment will help to re-crisp that crust and melt the cheese perfectly.

  4. Consider the Fridge: If you're planning to refrigerate your pizza, keep it in an airtight container rather than just throwing the box into the fridge. This will help prevent the pizza from drying out and losing its texture.

  5. Hydrate it slightly: If you're using the pan method, adding a few drops of water can create steam to help melt the cheese without making the crust soggy.

  6. Understand the Pizza's Structure: The starch in the pizza's crust tends to harden when cooled, which is why it can seem tough when it's cold. By using a method that heats slowly and evenly, you can help break down the starch again, restoring your pizza's original texture.

  7. Final Touch: Finally, after you've reheated your pizza, let it rest for a minute or two. This allows the heat to distribute evenly and can even help enhance the flavor.

Mevell Wood Cutting Board

Cold pizzas don't have to disappoint. Give them a fresh lease of life on a superior walnut cutting boards. Our cutting boards will not only make your pizza look and taste like it's just out of the oven, but also protect your countertops from scratches.

Shop now on Amazon and elevate your pizza game.


There is no need to despair if you find yourself with a fridge full of cold pizza. There are several simple and effective methods to reheat pizza so it tastes just as fabulous, if not better, than it did when it was fresh.

With a little time and the right technique, you can transform your cold, leftover slices into hot, crispy, and delicious pizza that's almost as good as day one. Remember, a good pizza deserves a second chance, and with these tips, you're sure to enjoy every reheated slice!

Related Articles

  • Cutting Board for Pizza - Best Pizza Cutting Board Buying Guide
  • How to Reheat Pizza in Air Fryer | Thick, Thin, & Deep Dish
  • 3 Creative Ways to Serve Pizza in a Party

Related Products You Might Like

While you're mastering the art of reheating pizza, why not serve it on a top-quality wood cutting board? A stylish and sturdy board can elevate your pizza experience and makes for easy slicing too.

At Mevell, we offer 100% Canada-made wood cutting boards that are not only aesthetically pleasing but also highly durable and practical. Whether you're serving pizza or prepping ingredients for your next meal, our boards are the perfect companion for every kitchen task.